Yesterday

Who Was Who—Back When Hancock Was Part of Sullivan
By Lois Crabtree Johnson

Special to The Ellsworth American

Hancock has an unusual history: For its first 39 years, the section then known as Skillings Neck, now Crabtree Neck, was part of Sullivan.

So, too, was Marlboro, today part of Lamoine. Finally, in 1828, Skillings Neck and Marlboro together were set off from Sullivan. They had added to them a large part of Plantation No. 8, creating the entity now called Hancock.

It is only in recent years, as people have searched for their family histories, that the interconnectedness of the early settlers has been found and understood. Many of these early families came from the same general area and were related. And these very details tended not to appear in family or town histories.

Because not every family had a sailing ship or teams of oxen suitable for a lengthy trek over barely passable woods roads, the relationships may help explain how people got here—and why. The original proprietors all had come from York and had settled in Sullivan proper.

Agreen Crabtree and Phillip Hodgkins Jr. are said to be the first two settlers of Hancock. But they were probably part of a group that came from the Bowdoinham area. There, they had been part of the “Maine Colony Company on the Kennebec River” in 1762, which also had included Eleazer Crabtree and Nathan Jones.

The Crabtree brothers came from Attleboro, Mass.; Jones came from Weston, Mass.; and Hodgkins from Falmouth, Mass. In 1768 Agreen bought 100 acres of land from Ezra Ide, whom we now know was a first cousin to Agreen’s wife, Sarah Ide Ingraham—both of Attleboro.

We also have learned that Nathan Jones, who settled in Gouldsboro, was a first cousin to Eleazer Crabtree’s wife, Lucy Traine, and to Thomas Hill’s wife, Rebecca Train, all of whom were born in Weston, Mass. So now it is all the more interesting to read in Thomas Foss’ privately printed 1870 History, that Nathan Jones helped Agreen build his double mill. It crossed the ledges and channel to Hills Island (Thomas lived there briefly before going to Gouldsboro), and from the other side of the island to Hydes (Ides) Point. It was truly all in the family.

Agreen, Eleazer, Phillip and Nathan were all sea captains, and could provide transportation to those who needed it. The original drawing card for most settlers probably was the stands of pine to be cut for masts—and most of these went to the King of England. Old deeds refer to “Mastland Creek” being located close to Agreen’s mills.

In what is now North Hancock, formerly Plantation No. 8, the McFarlands, Googins and Smiths arrived from Saco. But these families do not seem to have had any connection to other early settlers.

Stephen Young was a settler before 1784, but until this year, no one was sure where he came from; he didn’t belong to the other Young families in Hancock County. Now, not only is it probably that he also came from York, but that his sister Sarah was the wife of Ezra Ide, mentioned above.

Stephen and his sister Sarah had an aunt, Hannah Young, who married John Johnson of York—and they had moved to Sullivan in the late 1760s. Stephen was a yeoman (farmer), but obviously had relatives with their own ships. That may explain how he may have gotten here, and the relationships as his reason for coming.

John Alexander Cook was a sea captain (lost at sea in 1788). When he came from Scarboro, he probably brought with him his son-in-law, Robert Mercer..

Mercer married John’s daughter Christiana in Biddeford in 1787. Mercer was town clerk in Sullivan for several years, including 1827; in 1828 he became Hancock’s first town clerk.

On the east side of Skillings Neck, Capt. Thomas Moon was a prominent early settler. His origin is unknown, but he married Jane Salter in Marblehead, Mass., in 1754, and possibly came to Sullivan with Jane’s brother, Capt. Francis Salter, each having his own ship. Salter married and settled in Sullivan and had a family, but the Salter name no longer is found here.

Also from Marblehead was Francis Grant, who married Martha Baker there in 1752. Several years later he traveled from Marblehead to Nova Scotia and New Brunswick before coming to Sullivan. There, he became the first town-approved ferryman, located in the vicinity of the present Hancock-Sullivan Bridge.

His son Henry was born in Lunenberg, Nova Scotia, in 1767; he, too, became a sea captain. Today we can wonder, did Francis Grant know the Salters when they were all in Marblehead? Quite likely. They were the same generation.

The Abbotts, from Berwick, also spent some years in Nova Scotia before arriving here about 1770. Since there is no known connection among them and other settlers, I have wondered if they met up with the Grants and perhaps mutually agreed on where to go next.

Of course, there were other families in Hancock early on: In the 1790 census for what is now Hancock, there are 25 different family names.

I have found “connections” for half of them, and I will keep looking for others.
  

This site and all its content is the exclusive property of Ellsworth American, Inc.  Reproduction without permission is strictly forbidden.  If you have any questions, please send us an e-mail at info@ellsworthamerican.com