"We feel...there should be a back and forth,
with correct information," said Robert Moody, Wal-Mart’s
senior real estate manager for the New England region.
"We want to know the community’s view. We
are a community-based store.... We look forward to the planning
and zoning process, and continuing our tradition as a good
corporate citizen in this community."
Moody is responsible for the site selection and
development of new stores across New England, following them
through to their grand openings.
The Ellsworth store, built in 1993, has performed
well for the national retail giant, but is now inadequate to serve
the needs of the community, according to the Wal-Mart officials.
Keith Morris, Wal-Mart’s director of community
affairs for New England, said that in a "perfect world"
the present store would simply undergo an expansion. Currently, he
said, the store is "cramped" with merchandise, making it
difficult for customers to shop.
The present Route 3 location cannot be expanded,
because of the presence of wetlands. The corporation has a
purchase agreement option on a 32-acre parcel about half a mile up
the street from its present location—directly across from the
Myrick Street intersection.
The new site would allow Wal-Mart to open a
208,252-square-foot supercenter, complete with a grocery, general
merchandise, hair salon, indoor gardening center, photo
development center and a bank branch.
It would have 1,072 parking spaces.
The store would operate 24 hours a day.
The proposed supercenter is about twice as large
as the current store and would offer customers, according to the
Wal-Mart officials, "a complete shopping experience."
Proposals in Rockland and Belfast recently to
build supercenters have been challenged by local residents. A
group of Ellsworth citizens are exploring the possibility of a
moratorium on development.
Morris said such an action is not feasible.
He reminded the approximately 35 present at the
"Talk to Wal-Mart" forum at the Hilltop House restaurant
that Ellsworth is not a rural town, but an urban city that is
growing—commercially and residentially.
Morris urged business owners who have concerns
about the impact the supercenter may have on the area to visit
communities that already have similar stores: supercenters exist
in Augusta, Windham and Oxford. Rather than relying on rumors, he
said, "I would encourage you to do some research
yourself...talk to the mayor, the town planner, the local chamber
of commerce."
Morris said that in the majority of those
communities the businesses have remained, and some even grew due
to the additional traffic the supercenter attracted.
"Wal-Mart keeps local residents in the
community to shop, and it may draw customers from the fringe
communities," he said, "who will come and stay a day to
shop in town."
Morris stressed that Wal-Mart gives back to the
state through an estimated $1.2 million in charity on an annual
basis—averaging $50,000 per store.
Morris said the average Wal-Mart store in Maine
generates $2.5 million in state sales tax revenue. That amount of
tax revenue would require at least $50 in retail sales revenue.
Morris went on to say that "Ellsworth has
been a very good market for Wal-Mart," and that the local
store "has done very well."
In addition, he said, that statewide the
corporation spends $108 million on in-state suppliers, as well as
funneling almost $50 million worth of sales and property taxes
back into the local economy.
"How many millions and billions of dollars
have been taken out of the state and sent to Arkansas?" asked
Pat Stanley, a Bar Harbor resident and operator of several local
campgrounds. (Wal-Mart is headquartered in Bentonville, Ark.)
Neither Morris nor Moody answered Stanley
directly. Morris said that "money doesn’t get sent to
Arkansas," pointing to the $6 million payroll that goes to
employees who "work here and live here."
When Stanley repeated her question, Morris
explained that figure isn’t released "for proprietary
reasons."
"I rest my case," Stanley said.
"It is a national business—the money doesn’t
stay here," Moody said. "We are a part of free
enterprise."
Thelma Beal, an employee of Shop ’n Save, asked
what percentage of the new store’s additional hirings would be
full-time—and proposed that in the tight labor market it might
be difficult to find a workforce.
Morris said that of the 250 new jobs proposed,
about 70 percent will be full-time—meaning they will average
more than 28 hours a week. The wages and benefits packages would
be competitive, he added, with the employee search beginning about
six months prior to the store’s opening.
Wal-Mart hopes to open the Ellsworth supercenter
in 2002.
City Manager Tim King asked what the plans are for
the current store, once the supercenter is built.
Morris said that space will be sold. He said the
company is "actively negotiating with retailers" to
purchase the site.
King also asked whether the new store’s design
is "subject to negotiation with the local planning
authorities?"
"Absolutely," Moody said. "We
encourage the community to work with us."
Weston Kenney, project manager with Sain
Associates of Bangor, said the company must conduct a traffic
impact study, which is then submitted to the state Department of
Transportation for review. He said any action plan devised as a
result of that study must address ways to mitigate traffic
congestion and potential high accident locations caused by the new
development.
Kenney said that he anticipates working with W/S
Development Corp.—the Boston-based developer of the Acadia
Crossing shopping center (which will include a 116,000-square-foot
Home Depot store) located on Myrick Street.
"We’re a convenience store," said
Moody, "it behooves us to have our customers get in and out
as easily as possible."
Micki Sumpter, executive director of the Ellsworth
Area Chamber of Commerce, said that the meeting was "a good
beginning."
"I think Wal-Mart answered what they could,
but they could have been more detailed," she said. "I
think it was a good beginning."
Sumpter said the economic development committee
will sponsor follow up meetings with Wal-Mart officials—on an as
needed basis.
The chamber, she stressed, is eager to be in the
role of "communicator," between Wal-Mart—which is a
chamber member—and the local business community.
She said it is important that the community be
involved in the discussion—and kept informed.
"It’s going to be a long process,"
Sumpter said, referring to the planning department’s review and
ruling on the application. "People have to keep asking
questions. And Wal-Mart has a responsibility to answer them."