Bycatch
Herring Boats Fined, Haddock Hard to Avoid

 By Aaron Porter

ELLSWORTH — The coastal herring fishery will close tomorrow for the remainder of 2004. Having reached 53,840 metric tons of the 60,000-ton Area 1A total on Nov. 6, regulators decided Monday to close the area to all but incidental herring catches starting Nov. 19, the same date it closed in 2003.

Area 1A runs up the coast from Cape Cod to New Brunswick, and encompasses some of the most productive and easily accessible herring grounds in New England waters.

The closure isn’t a surprise. It comes nearly every fall at this time. But this year, it comes at a time when the herring industry has been beset by accusations of excessive groundfish bycatch. In three cases, those accusations led to formal notices of violation and fines levied by the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration.

The violations, all issued Oct. 12, cited each vessel for possessing illegally caught haddock. While the federal enforcement agents would not disclose the amount of fish involved in each case, they did note that the three vessels were boarded in port, where they attempted to sell the illegally caught haddock that was mixed with their legal herring.

The largest fine went to the fishing vessel Sunlight of Rockland. Her owners, the O’Hara Corp. and Joseph Martin, were fined $50,000 for the violation, which occurred in early August.

A $25,000 fine was levied against the owners of the Providian for a similar violation Aug. 10 in Portland.

A $10,000 fine was issued to the fishing vessel Challenger for similar bycatch violations in Gloucester, Mass., in mid-July.

The fines are a symptom of an emerging problem, according to Mary Beth Tooley, who runs East Coast Pelagics Association, a trade group of about 20 herring boats from New Jersey to Maine. While the letter of federal fisheries law states that there will be no bycatch of haddock or other groundfish by herring boats, Tooley said herring gear “has never shown zero by-catch.”

She stressed that it can usually be reduced and kept low. However, a marked increase in the population of young haddock in the Gulf of Maine will eventually lead to bycatch problems for more than just herring fishermen, she said.

“Herring is just the first one where it’s been a problem,” she said.

Tooley predicted future problems for fishermen targeting whiting and other groundfish as the haddock grow to a size where they stay in the trawl.

The problem has grabbed the attention of the New England Fisheries Management Council, which has created an ad hoc bycatch committee to address the issue. Tooley and others have requested that the group should first focus on herring fishery issues.

In addition to the government regulators taking action, Tooley’s group has teamed up with Associated Fisheries of Maine and American Pelagic Association to convene a Dec. 13 workshop in Portsmouth, N.H. Tooley said the effort is to bring together fisheries stock assessors, behaviorists, fishing gear designers and fishermen to work on the selectivity of herring gear.

For now, she said, many herring boats have been avoiding George’s Bank in efforts to steer clear of potentially expensive haddock bycatch. Other mid-water trawlers have been able to find herring not mixed with haddock, just off the edge of the bank. She said, with the closure of 1A most herring fishing effort will be confined to 1B for the rest of the year.

The New England Fisheries Management Council’s Herring Advisory Panel and Herring Oversight committees met Monday to review proposed policy changes that will go before the full council later this week. They are focused, among other things, on specifics of observer coverage for the herring fleet.

Send an e-mail to the reporter who wrote this article, click here.

   
   

This site and all contents therein are the exclusive property of Ellsworth American, Inc. 
Reproduction without permission is strictly forbidden, for more information contact info@ellsworthamerican.com